Two documents tend to land on a lab manager’s desk in the same quarter: the monthly gas invoice and a generator quote. They look comparable, but they rarely list the same things. The invoice shows what you paid last month. The quote shows what you would buy. Neither shows the whole cost. This post lists every line item on both sides, so you can build a comparison from your own numbers and trust the result.
What belongs on the cylinder side
Start with the invoice, then go looking for the costs that never appear on it.
- Gas and price changes. The per-cylinder or per-fill price, and how it has moved over your last few contracts.
- Rental. Cylinder or tank rental, including any charges for cylinders that sit on site longer than planned.
- Delivery and hazmat fees. Delivery charges, hazmat lines and surcharges.
- Changeover labor. The time someone spends swapping cylinders, leak-checking connections and purging lines, multiplied by how often it happens.
- Storage and handling. Cage space, securing, moving cylinders, safety compliance, regulator maintenance and training.
- Runs lost when a cylinder empties. A sequence that stops overnight, samples that have to be repeated, instrument time that goes unused. This one is hard to price, but it is real, so put an honest estimate in the sheet.
What belongs on the generator side
- Purchase. The quoted price of the generator and any options your configuration needs.
- Facility work. Placement, plumbing, electrical and, for hydrogen, room ventilation. Your facility team handles this work and any code approval, so ask them for their estimate early and put it in the sheet.
- Power. Ask for the unit’s electrical load and multiply by your local rate and hours of operation.
- Deionized water for hydrogen. Hydrogen generators run on water, and water quality matters. Count your deionized supply and the cartridge that keeps it clean.
- Scheduled consumables and preventive maintenance. Filters, dryers and cartridges on a documented schedule. A written preventive service plan is what keeps purity steady between visits.
- Compressed-air supply for nitrogen and zero air. These generators draw on compressed air. If you do not have a clean, dry supply, count either a unit with an integrated compressor or a separate oil-free compressor. Hydrogen does not need compressed air.
Why one payback number is not comparable
You will see payback figures in vendor material, and you may wonder why two of them never agree. The reason is that each rests on assumptions the other did not make: which gases are in scope, how many cylinders per month, what the cylinder price is and whether it keeps rising, whether labor is counted, whether facility work and compressed air are in or out, and whether maintenance is included. Change any one and the answer moves.
That is why we do not print a payback figure here. Yours depends on inputs only you have. When anyone hands you a number, ask for the assumptions behind it, not the result.
When cylinders can be the right answer
Cylinders can win, and it is fair to say so. If you run a single instrument occasionally, your annual consumption is small and the fixed costs of a generator are spread across very little gas. A short planning horizon points the same way. If that describes you, a cylinder contract with sensible delivery terms may be the better fit. The comparison below will show it either way.
A worksheet you can fill in today
Pull twelve months of invoices, then fill in one column at a time. Spread one-time generator costs over the service life you expect, and use your own labor rate.
| Line item | Cylinders, per year | Generator, per year |
|---|---|---|
| Gas or purchase (spread over service life) | ||
| Rental | n/a | |
| Delivery and hazmat fees | n/a | |
| Changeover labor | n/a | |
| Storage and handling | n/a | |
| Facility work (placement, plumbing, electrical) | n/a | |
| Power | n/a | |
| Deionized water (hydrogen) | n/a | |
| Consumables and preventive maintenance | n/a | |
| Compressed-air supply (nitrogen, zero air) | n/a | |
| Estimated cost of lost runs | ||
| Total |
Then run it twice more. Raise the cylinder price and see what changes. Then lower your expected utilization and see what changes. If the answer holds in all three, you can trust it.
Sizing basics before you request a quote
A generator quote is only as good as the demand behind it. Three steps cover it.
- Total the flows by gas. Count every inlet and every detector: carrier, split vent, septum purge, detector fuel and air, makeup. Use current setpoints, not the maximums in the manual.
- Add 20 to 25 percent headroom. It covers channels that are idle today and keeps the generator from running flat out.
- Count planned additions. If a second GC arrives next year, include it now.
Hydrogen, nitrogen and zero air each get their own total. You can read more about each family on our pages for the HG series hydrogen generators, the NG series nitrogen generators and the ZA series zero air generators.
Next step
If you would like a second set of eyes on your numbers, our Lab Gas Readiness Assessment walks through your instruments, totals your flows by gas and gives you a sized, specified quote to put beside your invoice. You keep your methods, and your facility keeps the placement work.